An Alternative Look at Alternatives
Key Takeaways
- Alternatives are being pushed into retirement accounts – A new executive order opens the door for 401(k) investors to access private equity, real estate, digital assets, and more, but this raises serious questions around suitability, fiduciary responsibility, and investor protections.
- The sales pitch doesn’t match reality – While banks argue that shrinking public markets force investors toward alternatives, public markets remain stronger than ever, with most wealth creation happening after companies go public.
- Risks often outweigh rewards for most investors – Alternatives carry high fees, illiquidity, and complex risks. For the majority of families, a diversified mix of quality stocks, bonds, and municipals still provides the clearest, most reliable path to long-term wealth.
From our Podcast#42 Live Plan Invest with Director of Wealth Planning Jeffrey P. Deiss, CFP®, AEP®, recorded Friday, September 5th 2025.
In this episode, we examined the growing push by big banks, custodians, and wire houses to bring alternative investments into mainstream portfolios — and now even into retirement accounts. A recent executive order, “Democratizing Access to Alternative Assets for 401(k) Investors” (August 7, 2025), opens the door for participant-directed retirement plans to include private equity, private real estate, digital assets, commodities, infrastructure, and even new lifetime income strategies. While this unlocks a trillion-dollar pool of retirement savings, it also raises important questions around suitability, fiduciary responsibility, and investor outcomes.
The Sales Pitch vs. The Reality
A central talking point in the alternatives push is the “shrinking public market” story. Sponsors argue that fewer public companies, delayed IPOs, and limited access to high-growth private firms mean investors must look to alternatives. But we unpacked the reality:
- Today’s public markets are stronger and larger in market capitalization than ever, with the S&P 500 alone exceeding $40 trillion.
- Most wealth creation — from Apple to Nvidia — occurred after these companies went public.
- Private markets often look better on paper due to survivorship bias, while many private firms fail or exit at modest valuations.
Why Banks Push Alternatives
We outlined five key drivers behind the aggressive marketing of alternatives:
- High Fees and Margins – 1–2% annual management fees plus 10–20% performance fees.
- Asset Retention – Lockups of 7–10 years or limited liquidity keep assets “sticky.”
- Institutional Mimicry – Selling the idea of investing “like Yale or Harvard.”
- Exclusivity – Framing alternatives as unique opportunities not available at discount brokerages.
- Market Conditions – With stock returns projected at 5–7% and bonds at 3–4%, alternatives are pitched as return enhancers or volatility hedges.
The Problems with Alternatives
We then broke down the seven major challenges individual investors face with these products:
- Illiquidity and long lockup periods
- High fees that erode returns
- Opaque valuations and reporting
- Complexity and hidden risks
- Uncertain return premiums
- Regulatory and tax complications (K-1s, delayed reporting, limited protections)
- Concentration risk and high minimums
The Bottom Line
Alternatives may serve a role for certain high-net-worth investors with long time horizons and strong liquidity elsewhere in their portfolios. But for most investors, the risks outweigh the benefits. Public markets still deliver the transparency, liquidity, and long-term wealth creation that alternatives often promise but rarely deliver.
For many families, sticking with a diversified mix of high-quality stocks, bonds, and municipals remains the clearest path to reliable, understandable, and flexible
Advisors Capital Management, LLC is an investment advisor registered with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply any degree of skill or training. All investing carries risk, including the potential for the loss of principal and past performance is no guarantee of future results. This content is for informational purposes only, can change at any time without notice, and is not investment advice or a recommendation to trade any security. Indices are not available for direct investment. We only provide services in jurisdictions where we are registered. Our disclosure brochure (ADV Part 2A) and customer relationship summary (ADV Part 3) are available at https://adviserinfo.sec.gov and upon request.
