A Thought Experiment
Assume a Vacuum
Albert Einstein used thought experiments to develop his theory of relativity — riding alongside a beam of light, falling in an elevator, chasing a clock at the speed of light. No laboratory, no apparatus, just a mind willing to run the physics all the way out and see what broke.
I’m going to use a thought experiment too, though mine is considerably less consequential. I want to conjure up the theoretical perfect investment: not a stock, but the ideal instrument, the one that serves a person from cradle to grave, morphing as its owner morphs.
Spoiler alert. It doesn’t exist. But the reason it doesn’t exist is where this commentary is actually headed.
The Instrument
Ages 0–25. Pure compounding. Liquidity is irrelevant — nobody is withdrawing. Income is undesirable. Volatility is a feature; the horizon is measured in decades. The thing is locked down so it can’t be tapped, borrowed against, or pledged to the wrong counterparty.
Ages 25–45. Growth develops a second personality. A liquid sleeve appears for a down payment, tuition, a business idea: the goals we’ve been saving for.
Ages 45–60. Tax alchemy. Losses harvested against gains. Pre-tax converted to Roth in the low-income years. A deliberate spread across account types so future withdrawals can be orchestrated to minimize lifetime tax rather than any single April 15th. Growth moderates but doesn’t quit — the risk here isn’t a market crash, it’s outliving the money.
Ages 60–70. The income pivot. An inflation-indexed stream the owner can dial up or down, drawn from sources that keep reported income beneath the thresholds where Social Security taxation and IRMAA surcharges sit waiting. A cash buffer covers a few years so nothing has to be sold into a bear market.
Ages 70+. Income, dignity, and legacy. Required distributions minimized. Beneficiary designations clean, current, and bypassing probate. Step-up in basis wipes decades of embedded gains off the taxable sleeve, the Roth passes tax-free, and charitable intent gets routed through the pre-tax accounts — a charity pays no income tax, which makes that the cheapest dollar in the house to give away.
Underneath all of it: radically diversified, low-cost, automatic, and engineered so that doing the wrong thing at the wrong moment is difficult.
That’s a fine piece of work, and most financial professionals would be out of a job if it were real.
Why It Isn’t
Here’s the thing about Einstein’s thought experiments, and about every physics problem any of us were ever assigned: they begin by assuming away the friction. Frictionless plane. Massless rope. Perfect vacuum. Ignore air resistance. The idealization isn’t cheating — it’s the only way to see the underlying law clearly. But nobody has ever built a frictionless plane, and the gap between the elegant answer and the working machine is entirely made of the stuff you assumed away.
My perfect investment assumes a vacuum too. It assumes the stage transitions arrive on schedule, announced, on a calendar. They don’t. They’re triggered by analog events: a pregnancy test, a layoff that lands on a Tuesday, a parent who quietly stops driving at night and doesn’t mention it, a diagnosis, the specific silence of a house at ten in the morning after a spouse retires and neither of you has worked out the new rhythm yet.
It also assumes an owner who behaves. That one is doing a great deal of load-bearing work.
The Digital and the Analog
I keep circling this because it’s the same shape as the argument consuming every market conversation right now.
A digital signal is a series of snapshots. Sample fast enough, finely enough, and you can reconstruct a continuous waveform so well that nobody complains — well enough to run the world on. Almost perfectly. There is always something between the samples.
That’s what artificial intelligence is doing to knowledge work, and that’s a feature, not a bug. The lifecycle sketch above is a sampling problem: slice a life into intervals, optimize each interval against a known rule set, smooth the transitions. A model does that in nine seconds and does it well. The analytical answer has become abundant, which means it has become cheap, which means it has stopped being where the value lives.
But every digital system is bolted to the analog world at both ends. There’s a sensor at the front and an actuator at the back, and neither one obeys Moore’s Law. The transformer, the turbine, the copper, the cooling water, the switchgear, the licensed electrician who can actually terminate the feeder — those costs go up, not down. That’s not a complaint about progress. It’s a place to look. When the abundant input gets 40% cheaper every year, the scarce thing bolted to it keeps the margin.
A meaningful share of the durable profit from this cycle will land on businesses with one foot planted in the physical world. Many of them are unglamorous enough to still be priced like it.
Friction Is the Product
The real-world approximation of my perfect investment already exists and has for decades: some weighted combination of a taxable account, a Roth, a 401(k), an HSA, and a trust wrapper, holding low-cost global funds on a glidepath. The engine is solved. It has been quietly working the whole time we’ve argued about it.
What was never solved — what I’d argue can’t be — is the willingness to leave it alone in March of a bad year, and the judgment to know which wrapper the current chapter of a life requires. That isn’t a computation. It’s a conversation, and it usually happens before the client has admitted to themselves that the chapter changed.
Einstein’s elevator was a vacuum by design. Ours has air in it, a cable, an inspection sticker, and someone standing in the corner who’d rather not discuss what the doctor said. The math is the easy part now. It always was, and we just couldn’t tell, because the math used to be expensive.
Assume a vacuum and the answer is perfect. Put the air back in and you have a client. Friction is real and impossible to assume away.
Advisors Capital Management, LLC is an investment advisor registered with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission. Registration does not imply any degree of skill or training. All investing carries risk, including the potential for the loss of principal and past performance is no guarantee of future results. This content is for informational purposes only, can change at any time without notice, and is not investment advice or a recommendation to trade any security. Indices are not available for direct investment. We only provide services in jurisdictions where we are registered. Our disclosure brochure (ADV Part 2A) and customer relationship summary (ADV Part 3) are available at https://adviserinfo.sec.gov and upon request.



